A K-12 music teacher in a rural area has been administratively suspended after she demonstrated a sad lack of judgment in showing a 10 minute
Faust excerpt to her 1-3 graders. She has been accused of being a lesbian (because she explained what a trouser role was) and a devil worshipper (the devil as Méphistophélès is present in Faust). This is a woman who is married with kids and is very active in the Presbyterian church. (See the link below for the article.)
It is my feeling that her 1) her lesson plan was more appropriate to middle/high schoolers; and 2) her point could have been made with many other operas. I would have been concerned about scaring them, since many of my 1-3 graders were scared of a
Hansel and Gretel puppet show --but the video in question was owned by the school district! The reaction of the community and the administration was WAY out of line here. How about, "This video is more appropriate to the high schoolers, and by the way, in the future you will send home a permission slip like you would on ANY OTHER VIDEO." Duh. Don't suspend her. It is like shooting a fly with an elephant gun; an overreaction fueled by ignorance and a fear of communal reprisals.
In other words, here is a teacher in survival mode--most likely distracted by prepping her middle/high schoolers for contest--who grabbed a video off the rack in a moment of "I forgot to do my elementary lesson plans!" panic...who is now suspended.
Just had a thought: there is a witch in Hansel and Gretel. She had scary red glowing eyes, makes little girls her slaves and eats little boys.
If you need me, I'll be talking to my lawyer.
Here is the link:
Playbill article